Sometimes the feedback we least expect becomes the lesson we need most.
“I don't know how to say this other than to come right out with it, but…it seems like you barfed this up.”
That was the feedback I received after submitting a few of the final stories for my book to my editor. She chuckled while she delivered the news, but I sensed she wasn’t kidding.
I wasn't new to direct feedback. A few of the first stories I wrote for my Homegrown Chef magazine column were sent back with notes from the editor like, “We're not writing Shakespeare here! Cut all the flowery adjectives.”
Even though I had spent years writing diary entries as a child, long research papers in college, and all kinds of copywriting in my work life, learning to write a thousand-word story was a new kind of skill.
While I’ve never worked a pottery wheel, when I’m working on a story, I imagine it’s a lot like starting with a lump of clay. Except in my case, it’s a huge pile of words. I have to spin them around and around in my mind, shaping them into a manageable form that I then try to get down on paper. And once on paper, there’s still more trimming and refining that needs to happen.
In the early days of my La Pomme de Portland blog, my goal was to share a relatable story from my life with some kind of meaningful takeaway, all tied together with a recipe. However, I didn’t yet know how to fully shape and refine my writing before sending it out into the world.
When I decided, with much encouragement from people who enjoyed my writing, to gather up some of my best stories and publish them in a book, it was my editor who taught me how to give them shape. A clear beginning, middle, and end. Something enjoyable for a reader to take in.
But toward the end, when I was rushing against a deadline to submit some new stories that hadn’t appeared on the blog, I didn't really shape them at all. I just sent them to her and hoped she'd give me the right feedback to fix them.
And honestly, since we were pressed for time, I hoped maybe she'd fix them for me.
Which is why, after she read through them, she gave those stories back to me with her very direct feedback.
And you know what? She was right. To this day, I laugh when I imagine what must have gone through her mind as she read those rushed submissions.
She couldn't rewrite them for me. They were my stories. I had to take them back. I had to find the time to spin them around in my mind again, trim out all the unnecessary flowery bits, and shape them into something that would be pleasant for someone to read.
I think about that a lot when I just want someone else to do it for me.
Yet I’ve found in my life that when I've pushed through something difficult…I feel my spine straighten up a bit. I feel a feather land in my cap. I hear myself say, “Good job, Carrie. Gold star.” There’s something about that feeling we can only get from doing the hard things ourselves.
Not all the hard things, of course. Some things deserve automation and efficiency. I'm talking about the things that are meaningful to us. The way we can notch up our confidence one little inch at a time by doing the work to create something purposeful in our lives.
I’m so grateful she was honest with me. Nowadays, when I'm trying to do something challenging that I really don't feel like doing, and I’ve put halfhearted effort into it, I can stand back, look at what I've created, and ask myself,
“Did you barf this up? Or do you need to take the time to shape it into something beautiful and meaningful?”
Cheers,
Carrie
The more life I live, the more I understand how precious our time is. What even a few minutes is worth. It doesn't go unnoticed that you spend some of your day here with me. Thank you for letting me be a small part of it. I hope you always leave with something meaningful.🤍