A Sorry! board on the floor, a ruthless grandma, and what actually brought us together.
In the early years of mothering, every parenting book, magazine column, and morning-show host seemed to agree on one thing: Friday Night Game Night. Pizza delivery paired with a board game or two, maybe even Charades. And oh, the list of benefits they touted! Family connection. Strategic thinking. Learning to lose gracefully and win with humility.
As someone who took her parenting job very seriously…some might say a little too seriously…I listened to these experts.
So, I implemented it.
Perhaps I should have considered my own family’s history with games before committing to this particular parenting strategy.
You see, everything in our family becomes some kind of competition.
When my siblings and I were young, my father invented a game called “Who Has the Longest French Fry?” Whenever we went somewhere like McDonald’s, we’d search our cartons for the longest fry before eating our meal. We’d each hold our fry toward the center of the table, where my dad would survey them to determine the winner.
Whoever won got to confiscate everyone else’s longest fry as the prize. Somehow, I only remember my father winning this game.
My grandmother was no different. She loved playing cards and tried to recruit me into games of blackjack, pinochle, and poker, occasionally bribing me with hot chocolate. So, I would play and she would win.
And then she introduced us to Trivial Pursuit.
My grandmother, a woman who completed The New York Times crossword puzzle daily, was unbeatable. And she showed no mercy, even to my little brother, who was probably five at the time.
"Grandma, can you whisper to me who was the British prime minister before Margaret Thatcher?"
“No. You’ve got to learn these things.”
I guess I shouldn’t have been surprised when our own Friday Night Game Nights didn’t go quite as the parenting experts had promised.
An innocent game of Sorry! (Toy Story Version) between eldest sister and younger brother started out well enough. Until older sister, with all the satisfaction only an older sibling can muster, announced “Sorry!” and sent younger brother’s Buzz Lightyear game piece back to the starting block.
He responded by sweeping all of her game pieces onto the floor.
“Hey, hey! It’s just a game!”
Apparently, learning to lose gracefully was going to take a little more practice.
I know plenty of people who genuinely enjoy playing games together. Two of my dearest friends will happily pull out a cribbage board and pair it with gin and tonics, looking like some impossibly cool couple from Mad Men.
For our family, however, game night was less about friendly competition and more about winning at all costs.
Eventually, I let the whole thing go.
But here’s what I didn’t fully appreciate at the time.
While I was trying to implement the experts’ recommendation for family connection, we were already building our own tradition around our kitchen table.
Most evenings, we gathered together for dinner. We talked about our day. We learned to take turns speaking, to listen to one another, to carry on a conversation.
Of course, it wasn’t always the picture of civilized family life.
In those early years, there was some tipping back of chairs, booger talk, farting, and enough general chaos that my husband occasionally looked ready to abandon ship.
But we kept at it.
And somewhere along the way, those noisy, occasionally exasperating dinners became one of the things I treasure most about our family.
Our children are grown now, and we don’t get to sit around the same table nearly as often. But when we’re together, there’s nothing I love more than lingering over coffee or continuing a conversation long after dinner has ended.
As it turns out, those family dinners accomplished many of the same things the parenting experts were encouraging. Connection. Conversation. Listening. Learning to enjoy one another’s company.
I’ve been thinking about that lately. While I’m no longer looking to parenting magazines for advice about raising children, there’s no shortage of experts telling us how we should be living our lives today.
How to stay healthy. How to manage our time. How to pursue our dreams. Much of that advice is quite good.
But just because a particular approach works beautifully for someone else doesn’t mean it’s necessarily the right one for us.
Our own temperament, our energy, what we genuinely enjoy. Those matter too. Maybe more.
So, if you’ve been trying to follow someone else’s advice about how to accomplish something worthwhile, and it just isn’t working, perhaps it’s worth considering another approach. The goal can remain the same, even if the path to get there looks a little different.
As for me, I’ll take a long, lingering conversation around the kitchen table over a game of Sorry! any day.
Cheers,
Carrie
The more life I live, the more I understand how precious our time is. What even a few minutes is worth. It doesn't go unnoticed that you spend some of your day here with me. Thank you for letting me be a small part of it. I hope you always leave with something meaningful.🤍